- Sponsorship -

Is Ranking 39th Acceptable? Effects from Snyder Tax Cuts

One tough nerd rolled to the governor’s office in January 2011 and later that year the Legislature handed him a huge victory at the expense of those who voted him into office — a $1.7 billion tax cut for business and a $1.4 billion tax hike on individuals.

The net result for schools was a $470 per pupil cut in 2011 and a long climb back to 2008-09 funding levels, with minimal per pupil increases that barely matched the rate of inflation. That means expenses continue to outpace revenue for schools, while Michigan business enjoys a tax bill among the lowest in the nation.

Five years later, the tax burden on Michigan business is at 54 percent of the national average, placing Michigan at 39th among the states.

All in all, Michigan is now a low-tax state, ranking 35th. Individual taxes are up but remain below the national average. Corporate taxes are down dramatically, due both to tax cuts and tax credits handed out during the Great Recession in hopes of retaining jobs.

No, these are not the observations of a long-time public employee embittered at the seismic change in our tax structure, public revenues and per-capita income over the past 25 years, but instead, the findings of a report published this month by the nonpartisan Citizens Research Council.

What does it mean for your schools? More of the same, likely.

The last two school aid budgets are good examples. Last year, the legislature increased the base foundation grant to $7,391, finally surpassing the 2008-09 base foundation allotment of $7,316. Twelve of Kent ISD’s 20 districts receive the base foundation while the remaining eight receive marginally higher amounts.  Some districts received an increase of just $5 per pupil last year, or almost enough, as one superintendent put it, “to buy every student one Jimmy John’s.”

This year, an election year, the governor proposed a $120 per pupil increase for the lowest funded districts and $60 per pupil for the highest. And guess what? Most in the school community were happy, even though it represented an increase of just 1.6 percent for the lowest-funded districts. As Godfrey Lee Superintendent Dave Britten put it, “At least it wasn’t a cut.”

If these two years arean example of what we can expect from state revenues in a white-hot economy where we’re pretty much at full employment, what will a downturn look like? A 1.6 percent increase doesn’t match the cost of living (a low 2.2 percent last year) and doesn’t match increases in health care, utility bills, student lunches or employee demands to catch up with lost pay increases. And remember, this is in a good year, one in which the Governor and the Legislature are putting money from the general fund into the school aid fund.

Recently, the Senate Education Committee passed a bill to eliminate the Michigan education standards and replace them with those from Massachusetts. Their logic was twofold: First, the Massachusetts standards were not the common core standards the conservatives can’t stand. Second, student achievement outcomes in Massachusetts are typically the highest in the nation.

While money isn’t everything, it bears notice that Massachusetts ranks sixth among the states in per capita income and is in the top quartile (11th) in state and local tax burden. It also is sixth in per pupil spending on K-12 education. Michigan, meanwhile, is at or near the bottom quartile of all measures and, oh, guess what, suffers student achievement scores that are in the bottom quartile on the National Assessment of Educational Progress.

Gov. Snyder, state Superintendent Brian Whiston and the Education Trust Midwest this year are all speaking about making Michigan a top 10 state in education. Whiston and Ed Trust acknowledge it will take more investment in education to make it happen. The governor needs to acknowledge that as well, or accept educational outcomes that mirror Michigan’s ranking in corporate taxes — 39th.  

- Sponsorship -
Ron Koehler
Ron Koehler
Ron Koehler is the Kent ISD Assistant Superintendent and offers his commentary on issues in education. Read Ron's full bio


Fourth-grade hockey fan gets a magical hour on ice: ‘I made the shot!’

Raised as a Red Wings and Grand Rapids Griffins hockey fan, Jackson Solow lights up while skating on an ice rink wearing his favorite hockey jersey...

‘This time it is continued learning’

One school’s switch from in-person to virtual education last week was nearly seamless, especially when compared with the forced school closure in March...

Foundation grants $28,285 in fall funding requests

Virtual phys ed and art experiences, materials to improve classroom focus and books on social issues aimed at middle-schoolers are among the grants approved this fall...

Latest school closings expand on state-ordered high school mandate

More Kent County districts continue to announce temporary school building closures, as schools contend with a sharp increase in COVID-19 cases in Kent County and Michigan...


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Related Articles

Have cart, will travel

A Southeast Kelloggsville Elementary music teacher has a new cart for her ukuleles, thanks to her school, her husband and the Kent Career Tech Center...

KCTC and KTC Core students roll up their sleeves to help reduce water runoff at Kent ISD

The water from the Kent ISD area feeds into the Lamberton Creek watershed. The plants will aid in reducing the amount added to the creek...

Essential workers get high school diplomas thanks to state program

Futures for Frontliners offers free community college tuition to essential workers. The program also helps people earn a high-school GED...
- Sponsorship -


Engagement: The Most Important Measure of Student Success

Polls find that students’ engagement in their school work declines as they ascend the grades. Tests that don’t relate to their real-life experiences exacerbate the problem...


Food ‘angels’ support hungry kids through pandemic

They work all across Kent County, guardian angels with peanut butter on their hands and crumbs on their shirtsleeves...
- Sponsorship -


Maranda Where You LiveWGVU