- Sponsorship -

All Rise and Make Your Case

Students Simulate Supreme Court Arguments

Hallea Michell strode into social studies teacher Susan McCaffrey’s classroom and approached a podium with a miniature White House on top and the presidential seal affixed to the front. “All rise!” she bellowed as she banged a gavel.

It was the beginning of a new case to be heard by the class of eighth-graders-turned U.S. Supreme Court justices. McCaffrey’s third- and fourth-hour students had broken into teams of two and three, then spent three school days researching cases assigned to them. One team served as petitioner and one team served as the respondent (similar to, but not the same as, plaintiff and defendant).

“We make this pretty official,” McCaffrey explained as she readied each table. “Everyone gets a legal pad and a bottle of water.”

Bryn Bishop shows her vote in Fernandez v California

In Loco Parentis?

First up on this day’s docket: Board of Education v. Pico, a case involving the First Amendment and a school board’s removal of 11 books from its junior and high school libraries it had deemed objectionable.

“Why can’t the books just go in a different part of the library?” asked Justice/eighth-grader Ainsley Workman.

“The school board can decide what is obscene, and even if the books were in a separate section, they’d still be in our library,” answered petitioner Julia Ernst.

After a handful more questions, Chief Justice McCaffrey announced it was time for closing statements. That’s when respondent Noor Duoibes looked from left to right. Her teammate was supposed to do that, and she’s absent, Noor explained.

“You’re just going to have to wing it,” McCaffrey said.

The crux of Noor’s statement: “Taking information from kids is just stripping them of trying to learn,” she said.

Petitioner Julia Ernst argued “in loco parentis,” which amounts to “the school district did what they thought was best for the students,” she said.

Teacher Susan McCaffrey collects Supreme Court votes

Past Rulings, New Angles

McCaffrey has led her eighth-graders in the Supreme Court simulations all eight years she has been teaching at the middle school, but she says other teachers have done it longer.

“They always surprise me, they’re so into it,” McCaffrey said. “A lot of times as they’re walking out of class, they’re still arguing their cases.

“And they sometimes come up with angles I’ve never thought of.”

McCaffrey chooses the cases, and tries to include a few that involve schools such as Board of Ed. v. Pico, as well as some cases that have yet to be decided.

Even if there’s been a final ruling, she said, “they learn that there have often been so many appeals that have reversed earlier decisions, that coming up with something new is entirely possible.”

McCaffrey said this year she’s encouraging her students to write to the real Supreme Court justices to let them know about their simulation and the results.

“I don’t think they get a lot of fan mail, and I can just imagine Ruth Bader Ginsburg getting a real kick out of it,” she said.


Supreme Court of the United States

- Sponsorship -
Morgan Jarema
Morgan Jarema
Morgan Jarema is a Grand Rapids native and a product of Grand Rapids Public Schools, including Brookside and West Leonard elementaries, City Middle/High School and Ottawa Hills. She found her tribe in journalism in 1997 and has never wanted to do anything but write. For 15 years she was a freelance journalist for The Grand Rapids Press, covering local schools and government, religion, business, home & garden and lifestyles. She and her husband, John, think even those without kiddos should be invested in their local schools and made to feel a part of them. Read Morgan's full bio or email Morgan.


Students reopen fine-dining restaurant six months after closing its doors

GRCC’s The Heritage has reopened to the general public, with culinary students cooking, baking their way toward degrees...

Plotting for a plot

Students’ hand-drawn maps are meant for the safekeeping of memories and to spur ideas for when they write personal narratives...

Outdoor lover, zen seeker, middle-schooler hope-giver

Bill Cataldo is the new K-8 principal for Cedar Springs’ new Red Hawks Online virtual school this year. School News Network took some time to get to know him better in this edition of Meet Your Principal...

The year of learning differently

SNN asked a sampling of students from across the county how it’s going for them so far in a school year of multiple instruction models...


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Related Articles

Making the best of it

Students, parents, teachers and others share their feelings about the start of this unprecedented school year...

Here come the students; schools try to be ‘prepared for everything’

Area school districts have to be able to switch instruction plans if the pandemic fires up again, and be prepared for the possibility of a COVID-19 outbreak in one of their schools...

Ready or not, school year begins as leaders adopt plans to teach, protect students

With most of Kent County’s public school districts opening next week, superintendents talk about their plans to educate students while trying to keep them safe from an unpredictable virus...
- Sponsorship -


Engagement: The Most Important Measure of Student Success

Polls find that students’ engagement in their school work declines as they ascend the grades. Tests that don’t relate to their real-life experiences exacerbate the problem...


Food ‘angels’ support hungry kids through pandemic

They work all across Kent County, guardian angels with peanut butter on their hands and crumbs on their shirtsleeves...
- Sponsorship -


Maranda Where You LiveWGVU