- Sponsorship -

Don’t Just Tweak the Telegraph

Broadening the Definitions of Student Success

Commentary by Kevin Polston, Superintendent, Godfrey-Lee Public Schools

One of the universal shared American experiences is our public education system. Our country takes pride in the roots of public education and how it has served to provide opportunity for any and all willing to grab hold of it. While time has passed and priorities have shifted, what we value in school hasn’t moved as much as one would think, beyond the historical beginnings of the compulsory public education system.

Content knowledge rooted in the “3Rs” has long been the standard, but as our needs have shifted, our practices haven’t. For example, our current education calendar was created during the time when the telegraph was the means of long distance electronic communication. Can you imagine if we only continued to try and refine the telegraph to make a better iteration? If we didn’t use current research and technology to rethink communication?

Related: Test-Driven Curriculum: Meet the 6Cs: Proficiency Demands Mastery of Other Skills, Experts Say – The messages of Kathy Hirsh-Pasek, co-author of the book “Becoming Brilliant,” and Lou Glazer, president of Michigan Future, merge two ideas:

  1. Schools need to better prepare students for the jobs of tomorrow.
  2. There is a framework for developing skills needed for decades to come, and it’s based on much more than content and testing.

Innovation is a hallmark of the American identity, but when the same concept is applied to education, we come to a screeching halt. It is time for our hard-working educators, and our system as a whole, to also work differently. The case for broadening the definition for success in school is clear.

Since A Nation at Risk was reported in the 1980s, our country has been scrambling for answers to improve educational outcomes. But due to the fact that we all have a common experience in attending school, we have what author Jamie Vollmer refers to as “nostegia.” He says the mix of nostalgia and amnesia leads us to romanticize our own experience through the system as “the good old days.” The reality is that scores on standardized tests and graduation rates are the highest they have ever been in this country, yet we are still stuck in quicksand.

Chart shows several skill levels for each of the 6 C’s

Even though overall national performance is improving, Michigan’s ranking in education has plummeted,and for students of color, is at the bottom. A “nostegia” mindset calls for refining the telegraph, rather than inventing the telephone.

There are other ways, supported by research and years of practice. Kathy Hirsh-Pasek and Roberta Michnick Golinkoff wrote the book “Becoming Brilliant” around a framework called the 6Cs to call for these changes. The 6Cs include Collaboration, Communication, Content, Critical Thinking, Creative Innovation, and Confidence.

Their research calls for a system to strike a balance between all 6Cs to enhance learning. This is in contrast to our current reality’s near-singular focus on content, and the historical values rooted in the 3Rs. Content knowledge will remain vital for learning, but the Information Age requires additional skills to analyze, construct and apply content knowledge.

An interesting twist is the audience of the book was parents, not educators. Children only spend around 20 percent of their time in school, so it was a logical shift for the authors to address parents. But their message resonates with the education community as well.

It begs the question, how can we reimagine our education system to provide a more meaningful experience AND enhance academic outcomes?

We cannot simply tweak the telegraph. It’s time to rethink why we do education and if it is achieving what we want it to do. The data calls for change, and the answer must include broadening our definition beyond the 3Rs to the 6Cs for success in school, and in life outside of school.


SNN profile of Godfrey-Lee’s new superintendent

- Sponsorship -


This student leader aspires to inspire

His advice: seize all opportunities, reach out to others...

Plotting for a plot

Students’ hand-drawn maps are meant for the safekeeping of memories and to spur ideas for when they write personal narratives...

Students reopen fine-dining restaurant six months after closing its doors

GRCC’s The Heritage has reopened to the general public, with culinary students cooking, baking their way toward degrees...

‘We’re educators; we always make it work’

Kelly VanDyke’s roots in Kenowa Hills reach back to her days as a student teacher there in the Resource Room. Entering her eleventh school year as a special education teacher at Central Elementary, she is preparing for new students, safety protocols and classroom learning, reimagined...


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Related Articles

Supply kits for online learners help ensure student success

Teachers find creative ways to get resources into students hands that align with curriculum...

Virtual community meeting Thursday to discuss district bond proposal

An online community meeting Thursday will give voters information about the Nov. 3 ballot proposal asking for a $17.79 million bond issue...

Ready or not, school year begins as leaders adopt plans to teach, protect students

With most of Kent County’s public school districts opening next week, superintendents talk about their plans to educate students while trying to keep them safe from an unpredictable virus...
- Sponsorship -


Engagement: The Most Important Measure of Student Success

Polls find that students’ engagement in their school work declines as they ascend the grades. Tests that don’t relate to their real-life experiences exacerbate the problem...


Food ‘angels’ support hungry kids through pandemic

They work all across Kent County, guardian angels with peanut butter on their hands and crumbs on their shirtsleeves...
- Sponsorship -


Maranda Where You LiveWGVU